Stop Prompting GPT-5 Like It’s Still 2023

Author: Trent Creal

Estimated read time: 6 minutes

Why Your GPT-5 Prompts Fall Flat

Most people are still talking to GPT-5 like it’s GPT-4 with a shiny paint job. That’s why the outputs feel generic, surface-level, or just plain off.

Here’s the reality: GPT-5 doesn’t work the same way. This model thrives on structure and planning, not lazy one-liners. If your results aren’t clicking, the issue isn’t the AI—it’s your approach.

The Big Shift with GPT-5

GPT-4 could grind out decent results with a blunt request like:

“Write me a marketing plan.”

GPT-5? Not so much. It’s designed to organize the problem before solving it. That means your prompts need to set up a thinking process, not just a task.

Better example:

“Break this request into core components. Build a structured approach. Then execute step-by-step.”

This unlocks GPT-5’s real power: structured reasoning that feels like a strategist—not a junior intern—did the work.

Four Moves That Change Everything

1. Set the Tone First

The model listens hardest to the first instructions you give it. Don’t bury your tone at the bottom of the prompt.

Example:

“Write in a confident, no-fluff tone for entrepreneurs. Then provide the detailed steps.”

2. Use a Spec Format

Think of GPT-5 like a project team—you need to define the scope clearly. Use four buckets:

• Task: What you want done.

• Format: How you want it delivered (table, bullets, narrative).

• Sequence: The order of execution.

• Exclusions: What to leave out.

Example:

“Task: Build a 90-day sales plan. Format: Table with weekly deliverables. Sequence: Start with goals, then strategies, then tactics. Exclusions: Avoid buzzwords.”

3. Validate Along the Way

Don’t let GPT-5 run wild. Make it check itself after each step.

Example:

“After completing each section, verify that it meets the requirements. If it doesn’t, adjust before moving on.”

This keeps your output tight and consistent.

4. Run Tasks in Parallel

GPT-5 can juggle multiple tracks at once. Use it.

Example:

“Generate customer personas, campaign themes, and channel strategies separately. Then merge them into a unified marketing plan.”

Parallel processing saves time and produces sharper, more aligned outputs.

Real-World Applications

Hiring:

Old prompt: “Write interview questions for a sales manager.”

New prompt: “Identify key competencies → create questions for each → validate cultural fit.”

Operations:

Old prompt: “Build a supply chain risk plan.”

New prompt: “Break risks into categories (supplier, transport, compliance, demand) → build mitigation strategies → confirm each has measurable contingencies.”

Marketing:

Old prompt: “Give me social media ideas.”

New prompt: “Define three audience segments → draft content angles for each → suggest posting cadence → validate against audience pain points.”

Bottom Line

GPT-5 isn’t here to be your task-rabbit. It’s here to be your strategist—if you let it.

To unlock that:

• Lead with tone.

• Use task, format, sequence, and exclusions.

• Build in validation.

• Run tasks in parallel when it makes sense.

Follow this formula, and GPT-5 stops being just another tool. It becomes a tactical advantage.

GPT-5 Prompts

Call to Action

Start small: take one of your old prompts and reframe it using this structure. Watch the difference.

If you want more tactical breakdowns like this, subscribe to The Supply Line // Tactical Ops Briefings for Entrepreneurs—your weekly edge in using AI to move faster, smarter, and stronger at TCK Worldwide.